Retail Media Has a Measurement Problem. Brands Are Demanding a Solution.

Retail Media Has a Measurement Problem. Brands Are Demanding a Solution.

peq-Stressed-Analyst-Facing-Conflicting-Dashboards

Retail Media Has a Measurement Problem. Brands Are Demanding a Solution.

peq ben flaccusBy Ben Flaccus, Chief Growth Officer

As brands demand greater transparency and independent validation, retail media networks have an opportunity to establish a more consistent standard for measuring incremental sales.

In a recent article for The Drum, Kiri Masters highlighted a problem facing brands investing across multiple retail media networks.

Four major networks, Albertsons Media Collective, Home Depot’s Orange Apron Media, Instacart, and Walmart Connect, were asked to explain how they calculate return on ad spend (ROAS).

All four use different attribution methodologies.

The findings, drawn from Ovative Group’s new Commerce Media Measurement Transparency Guide, illustrate just how difficult it can be for brands to compare performance across retail partners.

But they also raise a bigger question: Even if every network calculated ROAS identically, would we know which investments were actually driving incremental sales?

Four networks, four definitions of performance.

Ovative’s research highlights how differently networks assign credit for purchases. Some prioritize the last click or impression. Others distribute credit across qualifying interactions or weigh touchpoints based on when they occurred.

These differences can produce substantially different results.

A campaign reporting $8 in attributed sales for every advertising dollar may appear to outperform one reporting $5. But when those figures are calculated using different methodologies, the comparison becomes difficult to interpret.

And even if the calculations were standardized, attribution would still have a fundamental limitation.

Consider a shopper who clicks a sponsored product advertisement before purchasing something they already intended to buy. The platform may accurately attribute that sale to the campaign, but how much additional revenue did the advertising actually generate?

That’s why incrementality matters.

By comparing observed sales with a credible estimate of what would have happened without advertising, marketers can isolate the additional business generated by their investments.

Incremental return on ad spend (iROAS) provides a more meaningful measure of advertising effectiveness and a stronger foundation for investment decisions.

peq attributed vs incremental 1200x630 1

Brands want an independent perspective

There’s another issue we hear consistently in our conversations with brands.

Many have invested heavily in independent measurement across their broader marketing portfolios. Yet in retail media, they’re frequently asked to rely on performance results produced by the networks selling them the advertising.

We’ve heard brands describe RMNs as among the last media partners still allowed to “grade their own homework.”

As retail media captures a growing share of marketing budgets, that arrangement is becoming harder to justify.

The demand for change extends beyond our conversations.

In a recent Media, Ads + Commerce article, Andrew Lipsman made the case for RMNs to embrace independent measurement, writing:

“Integrating third-party measurement is a sign of media maturity and a vote of confidence in the value their platform provides.”

Lipsman also argues that independent measurement enables cross-media comparability, giving national advertisers greater confidence to shift meaningful budgets into retail media.

That’s consistent with what we’re hearing from brands, and increasingly, from the RMNs recognizing the opportunity to differentiate themselves through independent validation.

Retailers have extraordinary first-party data assets, sophisticated targeting capabilities, and valuable insight into shopping behavior. Independent measurement complements these strengths by providing an objective assessment of the incremental sales their advertising generates.


Incrementality needs consistency, too.

Moving toward incrementality is an important step, but methodology matters.

Earlier this year, Albertsons Media Collective, Ovative Group, and researchers from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management published Retail Media iROAS Demystified, examining measurement results across 42 campaigns.

Their findings were striking.

peq-incrementality-counterfactual-1200x630

Different methodological choices produced iROAS estimates that varied by an average of 6.5 times. In 83% of campaigns, estimates could shift from positive to negative.

The advertising hadn’t changed. Differences in experimental design, matching criteria, and incremental revenue calculations produced dramatically different conclusions.

This reinforces the importance of consistent measurement principles, transparent definitions, and rigorous methodology.

Brands need confidence that incremental sales and iROAS are being evaluated on a comparable basis across retailers, channels, and campaigns.

Retail media networks are responding.

The encouraging news is that RMNs increasingly recognize the demand for independent measurement.

At Pēq, we’re seeing this firsthand.

We’re working with retail media networks to integrate independent incrementality measurement into their offerings, enabling advertisers to evaluate campaigns using a consistent methodology and standardized measures of incremental sales and iROAS.

These partnerships are being driven in large part by the expectations networks are hearing from their own advertisers. RMNs are actively evaluating and validating our methodology, recognizing that credible third-party measurement strengthens their value proposition.

But the opportunity extends well beyond independent validation.

As retail media networks expand into in-store advertising, connected TV, influencer marketing, experiential activations, and other channels that have traditionally been difficult to measure, we’re helping them demonstrate incremental sales impact across a much broader range of investments. The same measurement framework can be applied across these environments, giving advertisers a more consistent understanding of performance.

We’re also helping networks look beyond their own transaction data. By incorporating broader retail sales data, we can provide visibility into the impact of campaigns across the rest of the market, including sales occurring outside the retailer’s own stores. That broader perspective is particularly valuable for brands seeking to understand total-market impact.

And increasingly, these partnerships extend into planning and optimization. Historical performance insights, pre-campaign forecasting, and in-campaign measurement give networks and their advertisers the ability to make more informed investment decisions, anticipate returns, and adjust campaigns while they’re still running.

Together, these capabilities allow RMNs to offer advertisers a more comprehensive measurement and planning solution, while reducing the operational burden on their internal teams.

For brands, the benefit is greater confidence in reported performance, a clearer understanding of incremental sales impact, and better information to guide where their next marketing dollar goes.

The next stage of retail media measurement.

Kiri Masters and Ovative have made an important contribution by exposing the inconsistencies in retail media attribution.

But greater transparency is just the beginning.

Brands want to understand the incremental sales their advertising generates, evaluate those results consistently across partners, and have that performance independently validated.

The RMNs embracing these expectations are helping move the industry forward while strengthening their own competitive position.

The next stage of retail media growth will depend on giving brands greater confidence in the incremental value of their investments, and making that value comparable across the marketing mix.

Everything is changing. Your measurement needs to keep up.

 

Editorial sources

  1. Kiri Masters, Four Major US Retail Media Networks, Four Different ROAS Calculations, The Drum, November 5, 2026.
    https://www.thedrum.com/opinion/four-major-us-retail-media-networks-four-different-roas-calculations
  2. Ovative Group, Commerce Media Measurement Transparency Guide, November 2026.
    https://ovative.com/impact/expert-insights/commerce-media-measurement-transparency-guide/
  3. Albertsons Media Collective, Ovative Group, and Northwestern University Kellogg School of Management, Retail Media iROAS Demystified, March 2026.
    https://ovative.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Retail-Media-iROAS-Demystified-Executive-Summary.pdf
  4. Media, Ads + Commerce, The Knives Are Out for Retail Media, September 16, 2026.
    https://mediaadsandcommerce.substack.com/p/the-knives-are-out-for-retail-media

 

Join

The Real-World Renaissance: Rethinking What Makes Advertising Perform

The Real-World Renaissance: Rethinking What Makes Advertising Perform

peq-real-world-renaissance

The Real-World Renaissance: Rethinking What Makes Advertising Perform

peq ben flaccusBy Ben Flaccus, Chief Growth Officer

As brands invest in physical-world advertising, a consistent approach to incrementality is challenging long-held assumptions about which marketing channels drive measurable sales.

For years, the advertising industry has divided the media landscape into two broad categories: brand building and performance marketing.

Search, social, and other digital channels have dominated the performance conversation, supported by sophisticated targeting, attribution, and conversion tracking. Meanwhile, out-of-home advertising, in-store media, experiential activations, and product sampling have traditionally been evaluated through reach, engagement, awareness, and other measures of consumer interaction.

But how much of that distinction reflects actual sales performance, and how much reflects our historical ability to measure it?

As investment in physical-world advertising accelerates, that question is becoming increasingly important.

The real-world renaissance.

Advertising is expanding into more of the environments where consumers live, shop, work, and spend their time.

Digital screens are transforming retail stores, transit systems, gyms, and entertainment venues into increasingly sophisticated media environments. Brands are investing in experiential activations that create direct consumer connections, while product sampling and demonstrations bring brands closer to the moment of purchase.

Investment is following. According to the Out of Home Advertising Association of America (OAAA), U.S. out-of-home advertising revenue grew 10.7% year over year in the second quarter of 2026, reaching $3.16 billion. Digital out-of-home (DOOH) grew even faster, increasing 18.5% over the same period [1].

Within retail media, the opportunity is particularly striking. EMARKETER forecasts that U.S. in-store retail media advertising spending will grow 33.1% in 2026 [2]. Yet in-store accounted for just 3.3% of non-Amazon U.S. retail media advertising spending in 2025, despite more than 80% of U.S. retail sales still taking place in physical stores [3].

The imbalance reflects how retail media developed. Networks built their advertising businesses around ecommerce, where impressions, clicks, and purchases could be connected more readily. Physical stores offer enormous consumer reach and proximity to purchase, but translating those advantages into measurable advertising performance has historically been more difficult.

peq ooh dooh growth 1200x630 1

The gap also reflects practical constraints, including inventory availability, infrastructure costs, and organizational complexity.

In a March 2026 report, EMARKETER identified measurement limitations, fragmented infrastructure, and organizational challenges among the barriers to scaling in-store retail media investment [4].

The same measurement challenge extends beyond retail stores. Experiential marketing and sampling programs create direct interactions with consumers, often at moments of discovery and trial. DOOH reaches audiences throughout their daily routines. Each offers distinctive opportunities to influence purchase behavior, but their sales contributions have been difficult to evaluate consistently.

As these channels attract greater investment, marketers need a more comparable understanding of performance.

Have we confused measurability with performance?

The rise of digital performance marketing was supported by an unprecedented ability to track consumer interactions.

Marketers could connect impressions to clicks, clicks to conversions, and conversions to attributed revenue. Channels that offered this visibility became central to performance-oriented media planning.

Physical-world channels faced a different challenge. How do you attribute a supermarket purchase to a digital screen in the aisle? How do you connect a product sample distributed at an event to subsequent retail sales? What is the sales contribution of an experiential activation or a digital billboard?

Historically, these questions were difficult to answer consistently. Marketers therefore relied on the measures they could observe: impressions, estimated reach, samples distributed, attendance, and engagement.

Over time, the industry’s definition of performance marketing became shaped as much by what could be measured as by what actually drove sales.

The channels that were easiest to attribute were not necessarily the channels generating the greatest incremental impact.

That distinction matters when brands decide where to invest their next marketing dollar.


A common standard changes the conversation.

Advances in sales-based incrementality measurement are creating opportunities to evaluate a much broader range of marketing investments against consistent commercial outcomes.

Using observed retail sales data and rigorous analytical methodologies, marketers can evaluate the incremental sales generated by campaigns across DOOH, in-store media, experiential marketing, sampling, and traditional digital channels.

This approach can work without linking an individual advertising exposure to an individual shopper’s purchase. Carefully designed test-and-control methodologies can estimate the incremental sales attributable to a campaign by comparing observed results with a credible estimate of what would have happened without the investment.

peq-incrementality-counterfactual-1200x630

The result is a more consistent framework for evaluating performance, using incremental sales and incremental return on ad spend (iROAS). Comparing results responsibly still requires attention to campaign objectives, scope, methodology, and uncertainty.

For a sampling company, that means demonstrating the additional retail sales generated by product trial. For in-store media, it means measuring sales impact beyond impression delivery. For a DOOH or experiential partner, it creates the opportunity to demonstrate commercial outcomes in terms that brands already use to evaluate digital investment.

A wider range of channels can now be accountable for incremental growth.

Rethinking the performance media mix.

For channels traditionally associated with brand awareness, consistent incrementality measurement creates an opportunity to demonstrate sales impact and compete for performance-oriented budgets. For brands, it opens the door to better informed investment decisions across the entire marketing mix.

It also raises important questions. Are certain channels generating more incremental sales than their traditional metrics suggest? Are some investments receiving disproportionate credit because their attribution capabilities are more sophisticated? How might media plans change if marketers compared investments using a consistent standard of incremental sales and iROAS?

Those questions deserve to be answered with evidence. No channel should receive a performance advantage simply because its attribution is easier, and no channel should be assumed effective without measuring its contribution.

As physical-world advertising continues to evolve, marketers have an opportunity to reconsider long-standing assumptions about what qualifies as performance marketing. The ability to demonstrate incremental sales should extend across the marketing mix, regardless of where an advertisement appears or how consumers encounter it.

Everything is changing. Our definition of performance needs to keep up.


EDITORIAL SOURCES

[1] OAAA. “From Coca-Cola to OpenAI, Brands Are Betting Bigger on OOH.” August 18, 2026.  Open source

[2] EMARKETER. “In-store experience becomes retail’s pressure valve in 2026.” (Citing its December 2025 forecast.)  Open source

[3] EMARKETER. “FAQ on in-store retail media: Closing the gap between demand and execution.” June 26, 2026.  Open source

[4] EMARKETER. “The Structural Constraints Limiting In-Store Retail Media.” March 2026.  Open source

Review note: The 3.3% figure excludes Amazon from the retail media denominator. The 33.1% figure is a forecast, not a reported full-year result.

Join

MMM Is Making a Comeback. But Marketing Measurement Needs a Revolution.

MMM Is Making a Comeback. But Marketing Measurement Needs a Revolution.

peq_beyond_the_identifier

MMM Is Making a Comeback. But Marketing Measurement Needs a Revolution.

peq ben flaccusBy Ben Flaccus, Chief Growth Officer

As the industry moves beyond identity-based attribution, the next challenge is connecting strategic measurement, campaign-level incrementality, and real-time optimization.

Last week, we explored a fundamental challenge facing marketing measurement: the erosion of the user-level identifiers that have long supported digital attribution.

Connecting ad exposure to an individual consumer, and that consumer to a subsequent purchase, has become increasingly difficult across fragmented platforms and retailers, particularly when measuring both online and in-store conversions.

The conclusion was clear: measuring marketing’s business impact requires a foundation that doesn’t rely on tracking individual consumers from exposure to purchase.

Now we’re seeing how the industry is responding.

The return of marketing mix modeling.

A recent EMARKETER article on the resurgence of media mix modeling highlights the industry’s growing interest in aggregate, outcome-based measurement.

According to research from EMARKETER and TransUnion, 46.9% of US brand and agency marketers plan to increase their investment in MMM, while 27.6% identify it as the most reliable measurement methodology.

The renewed interest makes sense.

Unlike user-level attribution, MMM uses historical, aggregate data to understand how marketing investments, pricing, promotions, and external factors contribute to business outcomes. It doesn’t require marketers to identify individual consumers or reconstruct their paths to purchase.

As traditional attribution becomes less dependable, MMM offers something increasingly valuable: a way to understand marketing’s contribution to actual business performance across the full media mix.

But the resurgence of MMM also exposes another challenge.

Understanding what drove sales last year isn’t necessarily enough to improve the campaign running today.


Three methodologies, three different jobs.

EMARKETER makes an important distinction between three approaches that have traditionally occupied different parts of the marketing measurement ecosystem.

Marketing mix modeling (MMM) provides the strategic view. It examines historical sales and marketing activity to understand the contribution of different channels and inform budget allocation.

Multi-touch attribution (MTA) provides tactical visibility. It uses observable consumer interactions to assign credit across marketing touchpoints, helping advertisers understand and optimize campaign activity. But its dependence on user-level signals limits its coverage, particularly across offline environments, and attribution alone cannot establish causality.

Incrementality testing provides causal validation. Through controlled experiments and test-and-control methodologies, it helps establish whether marketing actually generated additional sales that would not otherwise have occurred. Each approach answers a different question:

  •  Where should we invest?
  • What’s performing right now?
  • What actually caused incremental growth?

The industry’s emerging consensus is that these approaches should work together. MMM informs allocation, attribution provides timely performance signals, and incrementality testing validates the underlying assumptions.

peq_beyond_the_identifier_2

That’s an important evolution in how marketers think about measurement.

But it also raises a practical question: Why should brands have to reconcile three different measurement systems to make a single investment decision?

The problem with measurement that arrives too late.

EMARKETER identifies a critical limitation of traditional MMM: “Because it relies on historical, aggregate data, it cannot provide campaign-level or real-time optimization.”

This is where the gap between measurement and decision-making becomes particularly consequential.

A brand may have a sophisticated model explaining how its media investments contributed to sales over the previous quarter. But what happens when a campaign is underperforming today?

What if a particular audience, creative execution, or media placement is delivering significantly stronger results than another?

What if the optimal investment level has already been reached in one channel, while another offers greater opportunity for incremental growth?

And what happens when consumer behavior changes faster than the model can be refreshed?

A retrospective view of marketing effectiveness is valuable for strategic planning. But marketers also need the granularity and timeliness to make decisions while those investments are still in market.

They need to understand not only which channels are contributing to growth, but which campaigns, placements, audiences, and creative executions are producing results.

And they need those insights to be comparable across their entire marketing portfolio.


Bringing the pieces together without relying on identity.

At Pēq, we’ve approached this challenge by starting with a common foundation: observed retail sales and a consistent, identity-independent measurement framework.

Rather than relying on individual exposure-to-purchase matching, we use retailer store-level sales data, marketing activity, and advanced modeling to understand the incremental impact of brand, shopper, trade, and digital commerce investments across channels, retailers, and markets.

Our ecosystem connects two complementary capabilities.

The Omnichannel Performance Platform provides brands with a real-time view of marketing performance across their portfolio.
It brings together the strategic, cross-channel perspective traditionally associated with MMM and the granular, in-campaign visibility marketers expect from attribution.
But instead of depending on user-level identifiers, the platform analyzes marketing activity against observed sales outcomes using a consistent, standardized measurement framework for true comparability.

That allows brands to evaluate performance across channels and partners, with visibility into the contribution of individual campaigns, placements, audiences, and creative executions where the underlying data supports that level of analysis.

Crucially, these insights are available while campaigns are running, allowing marketers to identify opportunities to adjust investments rather than waiting for a retrospective model refresh.

Campaign Lift Analysis studies provide the causal validation, measuring to the UPC level using test-and-control methodologies.

ISA measures the incremental sales generated by individual campaigns, separating the impact of marketing from sales that would have occurred anyway.

peq_beyond_the_identifier_2

These campaign-level lift studies do more than provide a final performance report.

They continuously inform and calibrate the broader OPP measurement framework, helping align modeled performance with independently validated incremental outcomes.

The result is a connected measurement ecosystem in which strategic analysis, tactical optimization, and causal validation reinforce one another.

Rather than maintaining separate methodologies with different assumptions and performance definitions, brands can work from a standardized view of incremental sales impact.

And because that framework doesn’t depend on identifying individual consumers, it can extend across digital media, retail media, connected TV, DOOH, experiential marketing, sampling, influencer marketing, in-store activations, and other channels that traditional user-level attribution struggles to measure consistently.

From measurement to continuous improvement.

Bringing these capabilities together changes the role measurement can play in marketing.

A campaign lift study establishes what actually drove incremental sales.

That result helps calibrate the broader performance model.

The updated model informs decisions about which channels, partners, placements, and audiences deserve additional investment based on marginal iROAS.

And those decisions create new performance data that can be evaluated and incorporated into future planning.

Over time, each campaign contributes to a growing body of intelligence about how marketing investments influence sales.

This is particularly important because marketing performance is rarely linear.

Increasing investment in a successful channel doesn’t guarantee proportional incremental returns. At some point, additional spending begins to generate diminishing returns, while other channels or tactics may offer more attractive opportunities.

Understanding those relationships is essential to making smarter allocation decisions.

The next frontier is knowing what to do before you spend.

The greatest opportunity in modern measurement isn’t simply producing more accurate reports about what happened.

It’s using what we’ve learned to make better decisions about what happens next.

By combining historical sales performance, calibrated incremental results, and modeled response curves, Pēq helps brands forecast the potential impact of future investments.

Marketers can evaluate different budget scenarios, identify where diminishing returns may limit performance, and explore how reallocating investment across channels could improve incremental sales.

That creates a continuous cycle:

Measure what happened. Validate what marketing actually caused. Optimize what’s running. Forecast what comes next.

And then use the results to make the next campaign more effective.

The resurgence of MMM reflects a broader recognition that marketing measurement needs to evolve beyond individual-level attribution.

But replacing attribution with another retrospective methodology only addresses part of the problem.

Marketers need strategic visibility, granular performance intelligence, and causal validation working together, on a common foundation that doesn’t depend on consumer identity.

They also need to turn those insights into better decisions before, during, and after every campaign.

The future of marketing measurement isn’t simply understanding what worked. It’s building a system that continuously improves what works next.

Everything is changing. Your measurement needs to keep up.


EDITORIAL SOURCES

Join

The End of the Identifier Era? Why Marketing Measurement Needs a New Foundation

The End of the Identifier Era? Why Marketing Measurement Needs a New Foundation

peq_beyond_the_identifier

The End of the Identifier Era? Why Marketing Measurement Needs a New Foundation

peq ben flaccusBy Ben Flaccus, Chief Growth Officer

Advertising has become increasingly sophisticated at reaching consumers. Understanding whether that exposure changed purchase behavior remains much harder.

Across connected TV, retail media, social platforms, search and physical retail, marketers are assembling a more complex picture of consumer activity. Identifiers remain valuable tools for targeting, segmentation and personalization, helping advertisers find and engage the right audiences. But their utility for activating media doesn’t necessarily extend to measuring its impact.

Connecting an advertising impression to an individual, and that individual to a subsequent purchase, requires a level of identity resolution that is often incomplete, siloed or simply unavailable across channels.

The challenge isn’t whether identifiers still have a role in advertising. It’s whether marketers can continue to rely on them as the foundation for measuring business impact.

The industry is acknowledging the problem.

In February, the IAB’s 2026 State of Data report identified privacy regulation, signal loss, fragmented data and platform-embedded optimization as pressures on marketing measurement. It also announced Project Eidos, an effort to modernize measurement through more consistent standards and better cross-channel comparability [1].

The IAB Tech Lab has also published guidance specifically for environments where identifying signals are unavailable. Its ID-Less Solutions Guidance recognizes that advertising and measurement still need to function when a cookie, email address or device identifier cannot be used [2].

 

Identifiers continue to play a valuable role in modern marketing. For brands and retailers with sophisticated first-party data infrastructure, identity enables more precise audience targeting, segmentation, personalization, and customer engagement. These capabilities remain essential to effective marketing.

peq_beyond_the_identifier_2

The challenge comes when identity is used as the foundation for measuring sales outcomes. Connecting advertising exposure to an individual consumer’s eventual purchase, particularly in physical retail environments, requires a level of identity resolution and data connectivity that is increasingly difficult to achieve consistently across channels, platforms, and retailers.

As a result, identity-based attribution alone cannot provide a complete or consistently reliable picture of incremental sales performance.

Exposure data can only tell part of the story.

Identity-based attribution can illuminate observable paths to conversion when the necessary signals exist. Its usefulness diminishes when marketers need to understand sales effects outside those observable paths.

What happened when consumers were exposed to media outside a trackable digital journey? How did a connected TV campaign influence in-store purchases? What about a digital out-of-home placement, or media delivered inside a retailer’s physical stores? And how many attributed purchases would have happened anyway?

Answering those questions requires evidence about incremental business impact that goes beyond linking exposure and transaction records.

Start with the outcome, then choose the method

A more consistent approach to marketing measurement begins with a straightforward question: How many additional sales did the investment generate?

For brands selling through retail, observed sales data provides a common foundation for answering that question. Whether a campaign runs across connected TV, digital out-of-home, retail media, or in-store environments, its impact can be evaluated against the same commercial outcome: products sold.

There are different ways to establish that impact.

Individual campaigns can be evaluated through carefully designed test-and-control methodologies, using geographic or store-level holdouts and matched comparison groups to isolate incremental sales. At the broader portfolio level, advanced modeling can analyze patterns in sales and marketing activity over time to help brands understand the contribution of different investments and inform future allocation decisions.

peq_beyond_the_identifier_2

Both approaches rely on rigorous analysis of observed business outcomes, without requiring marketers to connect individual advertising exposures to individual retail transactions.

This creates a more consistent foundation for measurement across channels, retailers, and media partners, regardless of their ability to identify and track individual consumers.

 

Everything is changing. Measurement needs to keep up.

Over the coming weeks, we will explore the changes reshaping marketing: media returning to the physical world, shoppers behaving differently across channels, and the growing mismatch between platform-level reporting and business-level decisions.

Consistent commercial outcomes, independent validation where appropriate, and timely analysis can give marketers a stronger foundation for decisions across the mix.

Across channels and audiences, the essential measure of effectiveness is the additional business generated by marketing.


EDITORIAL SOURCES

[1] IAB, State of Data 2026 and Project Eidos (February 2026)

[2] IAB Tech Lab, ID-Less Solutions Guidance (July 2025)

Join

The Difference Between Measuring Search Performance and Improving It: Lessons From Walmart Connect +47% iROAS Result

The Difference Between Measuring Search Performance and Improving It: Lessons From Walmart Connect +47% iROAS Result

peq-walmart-connect-post-light-v3

The Difference Between Measuring Search Performance and Improving It: Lessons From Walmart Connect +47% iROAS Result

October 29, 2026

What if the most valuable insight from your retail media measurement isn’t how well your campaign performed, but what you should do differently next time?

That’s the question at the heart of a new Walmart Connect case study, highlighting how Pēq helped a premium sports drink brand understand the incremental sales impact of its Sponsored Products campaigns.

The headline result was compelling: a combined automatic and manual campaign strategy delivered 47% higher incremental return on ad spend (iROAS) than manual campaigns alone.

But beyond the result itself is an important lesson for retail media advertisers: when you can measure what your advertising actually contributes to sales, you can make better decisions about where to invest.

And that’s where measurement becomes a driver of growth, not just a record of performance.

The problem with measuring only attributed sales.

Retail media has a tremendous advantage: the ability to connect advertising activity to actual purchases.

But there’s a meaningful difference between a sale that can be attributed to an advertisement and a sale that happened because of that advertisement.

Consider a shopper who already intends to purchase your product. They search for it, see a sponsored listing, click, and buy.

Traditional attribution may give the advertisement credit for that sale. But would the shopper have purchased anyway?

This distinction matters enormously when deciding where to allocate a marketing budget.

Attributed ROAS tells you which sales were associated with advertising. Incremental ROAS helps you understand which additional sales your advertising generated.

Understanding that difference allows advertisers to identify investments that are driving genuinely incremental growth, rather than simply capturing existing demand.

The challenge: finding incremental growth in a competitive category.

A premium sports drink brand faced a familiar challenge: competing for shopper attention in a category dominated by well-established players.

The brand worked with Walmart Connect to increase visibility, drive sales growth, and reach new customers. Its Sponsored Products strategy combined two approaches:

  • Automatic campaigns helped expand reach and discover high-performing search terms.
  • Manual campaigns targeted relevant category keywords to reach shoppers at high-intent moments.

Together, these approaches were designed to balance discovery, precision, and efficiency.

But the advertiser needed more than conventional campaign reporting. It wanted to understand the incremental sales impact of its media investment and use that information to improve performance.

That’s where Pēq came in.

peq walmart connect post 2

What Pēq brought to the equation.

As a Tech Partner in the Walmart Connect Partner Network, Pēq provided independent incrementality measurement to help evaluate campaign performance and identify optimization opportunities.

The objective wasn’t simply to determine whether campaigns were generating sales. It was to better understand how effectively different advertising strategies contributed to incremental sales growth.

Pēq’s measurement brought three important capabilities to the campaign:

  1. Independent validation of sales impact

By measuring incremental performance, Pēq helped the advertiser look beyond attributed conversions and understand the additional sales generated by its advertising.

  1. A consistent basis for comparing strategies

When different campaign approaches are evaluated using the same incremental performance metric, advertisers gain a clearer picture of their relative effectiveness.

  1. Insights that can inform investment decisions

Identifying differences in incremental performance creates opportunities to refine campaign strategies, improve budget allocation, and pursue stronger returns.

This is the distinction between measurement that simply documents performance and measurement that helps improve it.

The result: 47% higher incremental return.

Across the April 23 to September 30, 2025 campaign period, Pēq’s analysis found that the combined automatic and manual Sponsored Products approach delivered 47% higher iROAS than manual campaigns alone.

The finding reinforced Walmart Connect’s strategy of combining automatic and manual campaigns to improve performance.

But it also demonstrated why independent incrementality measurement matters.

The advertiser wasn’t limited to knowing that its campaigns generated attributed sales. It had a clearer view of which strategy delivered stronger incremental returns.

That insight can inform how future campaigns are structured, how budgets are allocated, and how advertising strategies evolve over time.

The value wasn’t just the 47% performance difference. It was the ability to identify that difference and use it to guide smarter investment decisions.

peq-walmart-connect-post-3

What retail media advertisers should take away.

There are several lessons here that extend well beyond Sponsored Products or any individual retail media network.

Measure incremental outcomes, not just attributed performance

Attribution remains useful for understanding shopper interactions and campaign activity. But incremental sales and iROAS offer a different, essential perspective on the business impact of advertising.

Compare investments using consistent measures

Different tactics and campaign strategies serve different objectives. Understanding their relative contribution to incremental growth helps advertisers make more informed decisions about the mix.

Make optimization part of the measurement strategy

Measurement shouldn’t end with a post-campaign report.

The greater opportunity is to use incremental performance insights to continuously inform planning, investment allocation, and optimization.

Build a repeatable learning process

Each campaign should help make the next one more effective.

When independent measurement becomes a consistent part of the investment process, advertisers can turn individual campaign results into a growing body of actionable intelligence.

From proving performance to improving it.

For too long, much of the advertising measurement conversation has centered on proving that marketing worked.

That’s necessary, but it’s not enough.

At Pēq, we believe the greater opportunity is to help advertisers make better investment decisions before, during, and after campaigns.

That means connecting independent sales incrementality measurement with forecasting, planning, and optimization to create a continuous cycle of learning and performance improvement.

The Walmart Connect case study is a compelling example of that philosophy in action.

A 47% improvement in iROAS is a result worth celebrating.

But the bigger opportunity is what happens when advertisers can consistently identify those kinds of opportunities across their investments.

Because the most valuable measurement doesn’t just tell you what worked. It helps you decide what to do next.

Read the full case study on Walmart Connect


👉 Want to understand what your retail media investments are really delivering? Connect with Pēq.

Join

Retail Media’s Next Stage: Incrementality Measurement and Third-party validation.

Retail Media’s Next Stage: Incrementality Measurement and Third-party validation.

peq retail media

Retail Media’s Next Stage: Incrementality Measurement and Third-party validation.

peq cristina costaBy Cristina Costa

Retail media is under greater scrutiny than ever. As budgets grow, so does the expectation of retailers to deliver definitive proof of real incremental outcomes and actionable insights.

In his article, “The Knives Are Out for Retail Media,” industry analyst Andrew Lipsman makes a clear case for how retail media can meet that moment: get more rigorous about incrementality research and serious about independent, third-party measurement.

Those two ideas sit at the heart of what Pēq is working to enable for our brand and retailer partners.

Incrementality needs context, not just a headline number.

A sales-lift result alone does not tell a marketer enough. The context is missing.
What methodology was used? What were the baseline sales trends? What else was going on that impacted sales? What did the result teach the team about what is genuinely adding value? What does it mean for the business and how do I take future action?
As Lipsman argues, incrementality should be an ongoing learning discipline—not a static statistic.

 

Pēq unifies retail media and all marketing (brand, shopper, trade, and digital commerce) under one standardized framework, then goes beyond a headline incremental lift number.

peq retail media 2

Every result comes with the context behind it so teams know not just what worked, but why, how reliably, and where to put their next dollar.

Independent measurement makes cross-channel decisions possible

Marketers make investment decisions across an entire plan—not one media platform at a time. To understand relative contribution, identify trade-offs and move budgets with confidence, they need a consistent measurement approach that can operate across channels.
That is where standardized independent measurement matters.
Pēq brings disparate media and commerce signals into one performance framework, allowing teams to evaluate retail media in the context of the wider omnichannel plan. Rather than treating each channel as its own scoreboard, teams can work from a common view of performance and use it to inform future allocation decisions. 

The opportunity ahead

Retail media has a strong value proposition. Its next stage of growth depends on making that value work harder for the brands, more comparable and more actionable for advertisers.
Lipsman’s call for rigorous incrementality research and independent measurement is not just a response to industry criticism. It is a practical blueprint for building trust.
At Pēq, we believe better measurement is how retail media earns its place in the full plan—and helps marketers make every investment work harder.

Join