The End of the Identifier Era? Why Marketing Measurement Needs a New Foundation
By Ben Flaccus, Chief Growth OfficerAdvertising has become increasingly sophisticated at reaching consumers. Understanding whether that exposure changed purchase behavior remains much harder.
Across connected TV, retail media, social platforms, search and physical retail, marketers are assembling a more complex picture of consumer activity. Identifiers remain valuable tools for targeting, segmentation and personalization, helping advertisers find and engage the right audiences. But their utility for activating media doesn’t necessarily extend to measuring its impact.
Connecting an advertising impression to an individual, and that individual to a subsequent purchase, requires a level of identity resolution that is often incomplete, siloed or simply unavailable across channels.
The challenge isn’t whether identifiers still have a role in advertising. It’s whether marketers can continue to rely on them as the foundation for measuring business impact.
The industry is acknowledging the problem.
In February, the IAB’s 2026 State of Data report identified privacy regulation, signal loss, fragmented data and platform-embedded optimization as pressures on marketing measurement. It also announced Project Eidos, an effort to modernize measurement through more consistent standards and better cross-channel comparability [1].
The IAB Tech Lab has also published guidance specifically for environments where identifying signals are unavailable. Its ID-Less Solutions Guidance recognizes that advertising and measurement still need to function when a cookie, email address or device identifier cannot be used [2].
Identifiers continue to play a valuable role in modern marketing. For brands and retailers with sophisticated first-party data infrastructure, identity enables more precise audience targeting, segmentation, personalization, and customer engagement. These capabilities remain essential to effective marketing.
The challenge comes when identity is used as the foundation for measuring sales outcomes. Connecting advertising exposure to an individual consumer’s eventual purchase, particularly in physical retail environments, requires a level of identity resolution and data connectivity that is increasingly difficult to achieve consistently across channels, platforms, and retailers.
As a result, identity-based attribution alone cannot provide a complete or consistently reliable picture of incremental sales performance.
Exposure data can only tell part of the story.
Identity-based attribution can illuminate observable paths to conversion when the necessary signals exist. Its usefulness diminishes when marketers need to understand sales effects outside those observable paths.
What happened when consumers were exposed to media outside a trackable digital journey? How did a connected TV campaign influence in-store purchases? What about a digital out-of-home placement, or media delivered inside a retailer’s physical stores? And how many attributed purchases would have happened anyway?
Answering those questions requires evidence about incremental business impact that goes beyond linking exposure and transaction records.
Start with the outcome, then choose the method
A more consistent approach to marketing measurement begins with a straightforward question: How many additional sales did the investment generate?
For brands selling through retail, observed sales data provides a common foundation for answering that question. Whether a campaign runs across connected TV, digital out-of-home, retail media, or in-store environments, its impact can be evaluated against the same commercial outcome: products sold.
There are different ways to establish that impact.
Individual campaigns can be evaluated through carefully designed test-and-control methodologies, using geographic or store-level holdouts and matched comparison groups to isolate incremental sales. At the broader portfolio level, advanced modeling can analyze patterns in sales and marketing activity over time to help brands understand the contribution of different investments and inform future allocation decisions.
Both approaches rely on rigorous analysis of observed business outcomes, without requiring marketers to connect individual advertising exposures to individual retail transactions.
This creates a more consistent foundation for measurement across channels, retailers, and media partners, regardless of their ability to identify and track individual consumers.
Everything is changing. Measurement needs to keep up.
Over the coming weeks, we will explore the changes reshaping marketing: media returning to the physical world, shoppers behaving differently across channels, and the growing mismatch between platform-level reporting and business-level decisions.
Consistent commercial outcomes, independent validation where appropriate, and timely analysis can give marketers a stronger foundation for decisions across the mix.
Across channels and audiences, the essential measure of effectiveness is the additional business generated by marketing.
EDITORIAL SOURCES
[1] IAB, State of Data 2026 and Project Eidos (February 2026)