Retail Media Has a Measurement Problem. Brands Are Demanding a Solution.
Retail Media Has a Measurement Problem. Brands Are Demanding a Solution.
By Ben Flaccus, Chief Growth OfficerAs brands demand greater transparency and independent validation, retail media networks have an opportunity to establish a more consistent standard for measuring incremental sales.
In a recent article for The Drum, Kiri Masters highlighted a problem facing brands investing across multiple retail media networks.
Four major networks, Albertsons Media Collective, Home Depot’s Orange Apron Media, Instacart, and Walmart Connect, were asked to explain how they calculate return on ad spend (ROAS).
All four use different attribution methodologies.
The findings, drawn from Ovative Group’s new Commerce Media Measurement Transparency Guide, illustrate just how difficult it can be for brands to compare performance across retail partners.
But they also raise a bigger question: Even if every network calculated ROAS identically, would we know which investments were actually driving incremental sales?
Four networks, four definitions of performance.
Ovative’s research highlights how differently networks assign credit for purchases. Some prioritize the last click or impression. Others distribute credit across qualifying interactions or weigh touchpoints based on when they occurred.
These differences can produce substantially different results.
A campaign reporting $8 in attributed sales for every advertising dollar may appear to outperform one reporting $5. But when those figures are calculated using different methodologies, the comparison becomes difficult to interpret.
And even if the calculations were standardized, attribution would still have a fundamental limitation.
Consider a shopper who clicks a sponsored product advertisement before purchasing something they already intended to buy. The platform may accurately attribute that sale to the campaign, but how much additional revenue did the advertising actually generate?
That’s why incrementality matters.
By comparing observed sales with a credible estimate of what would have happened without advertising, marketers can isolate the additional business generated by their investments.
Incremental return on ad spend (iROAS) provides a more meaningful measure of advertising effectiveness and a stronger foundation for investment decisions.
Brands want an independent perspective
There’s another issue we hear consistently in our conversations with brands.
Many have invested heavily in independent measurement across their broader marketing portfolios. Yet in retail media, they’re frequently asked to rely on performance results produced by the networks selling them the advertising.
We’ve heard brands describe RMNs as among the last media partners still allowed to “grade their own homework.”
As retail media captures a growing share of marketing budgets, that arrangement is becoming harder to justify.
The demand for change extends beyond our conversations.
In a recent Media, Ads + Commerce article, Andrew Lipsman made the case for RMNs to embrace independent measurement, writing:
“Integrating third-party measurement is a sign of media maturity and a vote of confidence in the value their platform provides.”
Lipsman also argues that independent measurement enables cross-media comparability, giving national advertisers greater confidence to shift meaningful budgets into retail media.
That’s consistent with what we’re hearing from brands, and increasingly, from the RMNs recognizing the opportunity to differentiate themselves through independent validation.
Retailers have extraordinary first-party data assets, sophisticated targeting capabilities, and valuable insight into shopping behavior. Independent measurement complements these strengths by providing an objective assessment of the incremental sales their advertising generates.
Incrementality needs consistency, too.
Moving toward incrementality is an important step, but methodology matters.
Earlier this year, Albertsons Media Collective, Ovative Group, and researchers from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management published Retail Media iROAS Demystified, examining measurement results across 42 campaigns.
Their findings were striking.
Different methodological choices produced iROAS estimates that varied by an average of 6.5 times. In 83% of campaigns, estimates could shift from positive to negative.
The advertising hadn’t changed. Differences in experimental design, matching criteria, and incremental revenue calculations produced dramatically different conclusions.
This reinforces the importance of consistent measurement principles, transparent definitions, and rigorous methodology.
Brands need confidence that incremental sales and iROAS are being evaluated on a comparable basis across retailers, channels, and campaigns.
Retail media networks are responding.
The encouraging news is that RMNs increasingly recognize the demand for independent measurement.
At Pēq, we’re seeing this firsthand.
We’re working with retail media networks to integrate independent incrementality measurement into their offerings, enabling advertisers to evaluate campaigns using a consistent methodology and standardized measures of incremental sales and iROAS.
These partnerships are being driven in large part by the expectations networks are hearing from their own advertisers. RMNs are actively evaluating and validating our methodology, recognizing that credible third-party measurement strengthens their value proposition.
But the opportunity extends well beyond independent validation.
As retail media networks expand into in-store advertising, connected TV, influencer marketing, experiential activations, and other channels that have traditionally been difficult to measure, we’re helping them demonstrate incremental sales impact across a much broader range of investments. The same measurement framework can be applied across these environments, giving advertisers a more consistent understanding of performance.
We’re also helping networks look beyond their own transaction data. By incorporating broader retail sales data, we can provide visibility into the impact of campaigns across the rest of the market, including sales occurring outside the retailer’s own stores. That broader perspective is particularly valuable for brands seeking to understand total-market impact.
And increasingly, these partnerships extend into planning and optimization. Historical performance insights, pre-campaign forecasting, and in-campaign measurement give networks and their advertisers the ability to make more informed investment decisions, anticipate returns, and adjust campaigns while they’re still running.
Together, these capabilities allow RMNs to offer advertisers a more comprehensive measurement and planning solution, while reducing the operational burden on their internal teams.
For brands, the benefit is greater confidence in reported performance, a clearer understanding of incremental sales impact, and better information to guide where their next marketing dollar goes.
The next stage of retail media measurement.
Kiri Masters and Ovative have made an important contribution by exposing the inconsistencies in retail media attribution.
But greater transparency is just the beginning.
Brands want to understand the incremental sales their advertising generates, evaluate those results consistently across partners, and have that performance independently validated.
The RMNs embracing these expectations are helping move the industry forward while strengthening their own competitive position.
The next stage of retail media growth will depend on giving brands greater confidence in the incremental value of their investments, and making that value comparable across the marketing mix.
Everything is changing. Your measurement needs to keep up.
Editorial sources
- Kiri Masters, Four Major US Retail Media Networks, Four Different ROAS Calculations, The Drum, November 5, 2026.
https://www.thedrum.com/opinion/four-major-us-retail-media-networks-four-different-roas-calculations - Ovative Group, Commerce Media Measurement Transparency Guide, November 2026.
https://ovative.com/impact/expert-insights/commerce-media-measurement-transparency-guide/ - Albertsons Media Collective, Ovative Group, and Northwestern University Kellogg School of Management, Retail Media iROAS Demystified, March 2026.
https://ovative.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Retail-Media-iROAS-Demystified-Executive-Summary.pdf - Media, Ads + Commerce, The Knives Are Out for Retail Media, September 16, 2026.
https://mediaadsandcommerce.substack.com/p/the-knives-are-out-for-retail-media








