How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Media Mix Model
How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Media Mix Model
By Brian PozeskyAnd why LOYALTY PROGRAMS and Media Mix Models aren’t enemies — they’re the ultimate allies.
It was a classic Slim Pickens moment. The marketer was riding a bomb straight into the chaos of the modern marketing war room—hat waving, influencer budgets misfiring, TV under review, and no one quite sure if paid social was delivering real incremental value or just good-looking CPMs. And loyalty programs? Sure, they clearly provided value. But in the larger fight where they really winning any battles against the enemy?
Around the table sat brand leads, media buyers, CRM strategists, and some very tired data scientists. In the center stood the CMO and CFO. The CMO, playing the part of George C. Scott, animatedly pointed at dashboards and cried, “But look at the big board!” The CFO, stone-faced, responded with the line heard in boardrooms everywhere: “You’re wasting money. You’re fired.”
At the heart of the tension was the Media Mix Model—complex, often misunderstood, and until recently, widely feared. Once considered a blunt instrument for evaluating traditional media, MMMs were thought to be incompatible with today’s digital-first, personalized marketing landscape. But as the dust settled, a realization took hold: the model wasn’t the enemy of loyalty, personalization, or performance. In fact, it was the missing link that could tie all three together.
Modern Media Mix Models have evolved far beyond their roots in TV, print, and radio. They now operate across a fragmented digital ecosystem, connecting data from open web activity, walled gardens like Facebook and Amazon, and even offline channels like in-store promotions and direct mail.
Powered by machine learning and real-time data ingestion, today’s MMMs can measure incremental impact across media types with a level of granularity that would have been unthinkable even a few years ago.
And it’s precisely this granularity that reframes the relationship between MMM and loyalty.
Where marketers once had to choose between broad media strategies and highly personalized engagement, they can now align the two.
This isn’t just a theoretical synergy—it’s increasingly operational. Media Mix Model outputs now feed directly into the programmatic media supply chain. A model might identify that CTV or paid social is outperforming other channels in a specific region or demographic. Loyalty data can then provide the exact IDs and behaviors needed to define high-value audience segments.
Together, they enable marketers to not only allocate spend more effectively, but also to activate it more precisely.
In other words, Media Mix Models aren’t just compatible with loyalty—they’re becoming loyalty. The lines are blurring. MMMs now inform everything from channel mix to creative testing to individualized targeting. And loyalty data, once confined to retention programs, now helps fuel top-of-funnel performance and attribution. The result is a more integrated, closed-loop marketing system—one where macro strategy and micro execution finally speak the same language.
This evolution also means marketing teams are operating more cohesively. MMMs are no longer the exclusive domain of data scientists, buried in quarterly decks. They’ve become living tools that feed into daily marketing decisions. Brand, media, CRM, and finance teams now share a common view of what’s working, why it’s working, and how to optimize it.
Unlike the catastrophic ending of Dr. Strangelove, today’s marketers aren’t plunging into chaos. They’re steering the ship with data, insight, and increasing confidence. Media Mix Models and Loyalty Programs—once seen as separate, even conflicting forces—have become the marketing world’s odd couple: unlikely partners who, together, are more powerful than either alone.
It turns out the secret weapon wasn’t panic, or budget cuts, or viral stunts. It was understanding that strategy and personalization don’t need to be opposites. They just needed a better way to connect. And thanks to modern MMMs and loyalty data, that connection has finally arrived—with data-driven cowboy confidence leading the way.
Ready to Ditch the Dashboard Chaos?
Start with a Free Incrementality Audit and discover where your marketing is really making an impact—and where it’s just making noise.
👉 Get your Free Incrementality Audit
